Last reviewed November 2026.
Short answer
The signs you need a new website are a site that is hard to use on a phone, loads slowly, shows security warnings, cannot be edited by you, looks out of date, gives wrong information, fails accessibility checks, runs on old software, or brings no calls. One small fail is usually fixable. Count the big fails: zero or one means repair, two or three means refresh, and four or more means price a rebuild.
Most lists of warning signs ask you to trust your gut. This one asks you to test. Each sign below comes with a check that takes about five minutes, and a scorecard at the end tells you whether to repair or replace.
This guide is part of our website redesign guide.
In this guide
- What “needs a new website” really means
- The nine signs at a glance
- Sign 1: It is hard to use on a phone
- Sign 2: It loads slowly
- Sign 3: Your browser shows a security warning
- Sign 4: You cannot update it yourself
- Sign 5: It looks out of date
- Sign 6: It does not bring in calls or forms
- Sign 7: The information is wrong or missing
- Sign 8: It fails basic accessibility checks
- Sign 9: It runs on old software
- The scorecard
- A made-up example with the math
- Reasons that are not signs
- What a new site will not fix
- Repair, refresh or rebuild
- Your 15-minute test for today
- Common mistakes
- Frequently asked questions
- Next steps
What “needs a new website” really means
A website is a tool. It should help a stranger understand what you do, trust you and contact you. When it stops doing that, you have a problem to solve. The fix might be small. It might be a full rebuild.
Three terms help here:
- Repair. Fix specific problems on the current site. The structure stays.
- Refresh. Update the look, the words and the key pages. The structure mostly stays.
- Rebuild. Start over on a new structure, often on a new platform. Content and addresses are moved with care.
A lead is a call, a form or a message from someone who wants your service. Count leads, not visits. We use that word often below.
The question is not “is my site old?” The question is “which of these nine things is failing, and how deep does the failure go?” That is the difference between this guide and our website audit guide. The audit comes after you decide something is wrong. These tests tell you whether something is wrong at all.
The nine signs at a glance
| # | Sign | Five-minute test | Passing looks like |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hard to use on a phone | Open the site on your phone | Readable without zooming, no sideways scroll, tappable menu and phone number |
| 2 | Loads slowly | Run PageSpeed Insights on mobile | Lab test: main content (LCP) within 2.5 seconds, layout shift (CLS) 0.1 or less, low Total Blocking Time. Real-user data, if shown, passes too |
| 3 | Security warning | Open the site in a private window | Lock icon, no warning page |
| 4 | You cannot update it | Change one line of text | Done in five minutes by you |
| 5 | Looks out of date | Compare with two competitors | You would trust yours as much as theirs |
| 6 | No calls or forms | Count leads from the last three months | You can count them, and the count is not shrinking |
| 7 | Wrong or missing information | Read every page once | Hours, services, staff and prices are correct |
| 8 | Fails accessibility checks | Tab through with a keyboard | You can reach the menu and form; text contrast meets 4.5 to 1 |
| 9 | Old software | Look at your dashboard | Few updates waiting, recent backup, no unknown plugins |
Mark each row pass, small fail or big fail as you read. A small fail is a quick, cheap fix. A big fail is a problem in the structure, the platform or your control of the site.
Sign 1: It is hard to use on a phone
This is the first test because it matters most. Older sites were often made for a desktop screen. On a phone they show tiny text, sideways scrolling and buttons you cannot tap.
It also matters to search. Google Search Central says: “Google uses the mobile version of a site’s content, crawled with the smartphone agent for indexing and ranking.” If your phone version is weak, that weak version is the one Google reads.
The test for sign 1
- Open your homepage on your own phone.
- Can you read the headline without zooming in?
- Can you open the menu and tap your phone number?
- Does the page ever slide sideways?
- Open your two most important service pages. Repeat the same checks.
Small fail: one odd button or an image that is too wide. Big fail: the whole layout is built at a fixed desktop width. Our mobile-ready checklist has ten more checks.
Sign 2: It loads slowly
Slow pages make people wait, and waiting is a reason to leave. Google tracks three Core Web Vitals. web.dev lists the good targets: the main content should appear “within 2.5 seconds of when the page first starts loading,” pages should respond in “200 milliseconds or less,” and layout shift should be “0.1 or less.” These are measured at the 75th percentile of page loads. In plain words, most visits should meet the targets, not just the best ones. Google’s PageSpeed Insights notes that a page “might not have sufficient data if it has been recently published or has too few samples from real users.” Small sites often see no real-user numbers, so the steps below also use the lab test.
The test for sign 2
- Go to PageSpeed Insights and enter your homepage address.
- Read the mobile result first, not the desktop one.
- Write down the lab numbers for Largest Contentful Paint (main content time), Cumulative Layout Shift and Total Blocking Time. The lab test reports Total Blocking Time, not response time.
- Look for the real-user section at the top. It can be missing when a page has too few visits. If it is missing, use the lab numbers, or open the Core Web Vitals report in Google Search Console if you have it set up.
- Test one service page too. Homepages are often tuned, inner pages are not.
Small fail: a few huge photos. Shrink them and retest. Big fail: a bloated build with many plugins and a slow host, where fixes help a little and the numbers still miss. Our 12-step speed checklist lists the fixes to try first.
Sign 3: Your browser shows a security warning
Secure sites use HTTPS. When something is wrong, browsers can show “Not secure” or a full warning page. A visitor who sees that may not trust you enough to try a contact form.
The test for sign 3
- Type your address into a private browser window.
- Look for a lock icon and no warning.
- Try the address with and without “www.” Both should land on the same secure page.
- Fill out your own contact form and watch for a warning before it sends.
Small fail: an expired certificate. That is usually a quick fix at your host. Big fail: repeated warnings, hacked pages or spam links that return after you clean them. That points to a deeper problem with software or hosting.
Sign 4: You cannot update it yourself
If changing your hours means calling someone and waiting a week, the site is working against you. Prices, photos and phone numbers go stale. Visitors see the old version and act on it.
The test for sign 4
Log in and change one line of text on your homepage. Time yourself. If you cannot log in, if you do not know who can, or if it takes more than five minutes, mark a fail.
Small fail: you lost the login but the platform is easy. Big fail: only the original developer can make changes, or you do not own your domain and content. Ownership is the point to check first. You should hold the keys to your domain name and your site files.
Sign 5: It looks out of date
People judge a business fast, and a tired look can suggest a tired business. Common clues are tiny text, crowded layouts, auto-playing sliders, photos of strangers and a copyright year from long ago.

Be careful here. Look alone is the weakest sign on this list. A new look does not bring calls by itself. Treat a dated look as a sign only when it comes with other fails.
The test for sign 5
- Search for your main service plus your town.
- Open the top three organic results in separate tabs, including yours if it shows.
- Ask one question: which of these would I call first, and why?
- Show the three homepages to someone who does not know the business. Ask them the same question.
Small fail: old photos and a stale copyright year. Big fail: a dated structure, such as a homepage with no clear next step. See our web design tips for quick wins.
Sign 6: It does not bring in calls or forms
This is the sign that costs the most. A site can look fine and still bring nothing. It may not say what you do in the first line. It may bury the phone number. It may use a long form that asks for too much.
Check that you can measure this. Google Analytics and Google Search Console are free. Search Console shows how Google finds and shows your pages. Analytics shows what visitors do on them.
The test for sign 6
- Count the calls and form messages from the last three months. Check your phone log and your email.
- Open Analytics and note how many people visited in the same months.
- Divide leads by visits. That is your rough contact rate.
- Compare to the three months before. Is it falling, flat or rising?
Small fail: a weak headline or a form with too many fields. Big fail: no tracking, no clear path from the homepage to a contact step, and no one who can add either. If you cannot count your leads, treat that as a fail by itself. Our guide on redesigning for lead generation shows eight changes that help visitors reach you.
Sign 7: The information is wrong or missing
Old hours. A closed location. A service you dropped three years ago. A service you now sell that has no page at all. Customers act on what they see, and wrong facts waste their time and your credibility.
The test for sign 7
- Read every page once, slowly, as a customer would.
- Mark every wrong fact: hours, prices, names, addresses, service areas.
- List the services you sell today. Check that each one has its own page.
- Check that your name, address and phone number match your Google Business Profile.
Small fail: a few old facts. Big fail: most content is out of date, or the site cannot grow because adding a page is a project. Before you rebuild, a content inventory tells you which pages are worth keeping.
Sign 8: It fails basic accessibility checks
Some visitors use screen readers, keyboards or large text. This is a service issue and a business risk. The U.S. Department of Justice says Title III of the ADA “prohibits discrimination against people with disabilities by businesses open to the public,” and that a website with inaccessible features can limit access to a business’s goods and services. It names the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) as helpful guidance. This is not legal advice. Ask a lawyer about your own situation.
The test for sign 8
- Put your mouse aside. Press the Tab key repeatedly on your homepage.
- Can you reach the menu, the links and the contact form? Can you see where the focus is?
- Check that text stands out from its background. W3C sets a contrast ratio of at least 4.5:1 for normal text and 3:1 for large text.
- Check that every meaningful image has a short text description.
Small fail: low-contrast buttons or missing image descriptions. Big fail: a layout that traps the keyboard or hides the menu from it. Our accessibility basics lists twelve checks.
Sign 9: It runs on old software
If your site runs on WordPress, read this. The WordPress developer documentation says “you should always keep up to date with the latest version of WordPress” and “make sure your plugins are always updated.” It also says to delete a plugin you are not using, and to “back up your data regularly.”
The test for sign 9
- Log in to your dashboard.
- Count the updates waiting for core, plugins and themes.
- Look for plugins you do not recognize or no longer use.
- Ask your host or developer when the last backup ran, and whether you can restore from it.
Small fail: a handful of updates waiting. Big fail: a theme or plugin that is abandoned, or updates that break the site every time you run them. If the code is the problem, an ongoing maintenance routine keeps the next site from ending up the same way.
The scorecard
Now count. Use this table to rate each sign you tested.
| Sign | Small fail (repair) | Big fail (replace) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Phone | One odd button | Whole layout is fixed-width |
| 2. Speed | Large images | Bloated build, slow host |
| 3. Security | Expired certificate | Repeated hacks or spam links |
| 4. Editing | Lost login on an easy platform | Only one developer can edit, or you do not own the site |
| 5. Look | Dated photos | Dated structure and layout |
| 6. Results | Weak headline | No tracking and no clear path to contact you |
| 7. Accuracy | A few old facts | Content is mostly outdated |
| 8. Accessibility | Low contrast | Layout blocks keyboard use |
| 9. Software | Updates waiting | Abandoned theme or plugins |
Count your big fails:
| Big fails | What it suggests | Next move |
|---|---|---|
| 0 or 1 | Repair | Fix the failing items, then retest in a month |
| 2 or 3 | Refresh | Fix the worst problems first and plan updates to the key pages |
| 4 or more | Rebuild | Get written quotes and plan the move before you start |
These cut-offs are rules of thumb we use, not a formula. Use them to start a conversation, not to end one. A single big fail, such as no ownership of your own site, can justify a rebuild alone.
A made-up example with the math
This example is made up. The numbers are round and are not from a real client. Use it to learn the method, then use your own numbers.
A small electrical contractor in Central PA runs the nine tests. The scores:
| Sign | Result | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Phone | Menu will not open; text is tiny | Big fail |
| 2. Speed | Slow on mobile; one huge hero photo | Small fail |
| 3. Security | Lock icon shows | Pass |
| 4. Editing | Only the former developer has the login | Big fail |
| 5. Look | Dated but clean | Small fail |
| 6. Results | No tracking; owner cannot say how many leads | Big fail |
| 7. Accuracy | Two old service pages | Small fail |
| 8. Accessibility | Low-contrast buttons | Small fail |
| 9. Software | Three plugin updates waiting | Small fail |
That is three big fails, so the scorecard says refresh: fix the worst problems first and retest. It is not yet a rebuild, which starts at four. Still, the lack of control over the site is the one to fix first. In the meantime the owner shrinks the hero photo, runs the updates and finds the login.
Now the money side, also made up. Say the site gets 400 visits a month and brings 4 leads. That is a 1 percent contact rate (4 ÷ 400). After a rebuild with a working phone layout and a clear contact button, say the same 400 visits bring 8 leads, or 2 percent. The owner books 1 in 4 leads and each job earns $800 in gross profit.
| Step | Before | After | Math |
|---|---|---|---|
| Visits per month | 400 | 400 | Assumed the same |
| Leads per month | 4 | 8 | 1% and 2% of 400 |
| Jobs booked | 1 | 2 | 1 in 4 leads |
| Gross profit | $800 | $1,600 | Jobs × $800 |
| Difference | $800 a month | $1,600 − $800 |
Over a year that is $9,600 (12 × $800). Those figures are invented. Real results depend on your market, your phone answering and your offer, and nobody can promise them. The method is the useful part: measure your contact rate now, so you can tell later whether the change worked.
Not sure how your site scores? Try our free Website Teardown, or see our website redesign service.
Reasons that are not signs
Some reasons feel urgent but should not decide the question alone.

| Reason | Why it is not enough | What to do instead |
|---|---|---|
| “It is three years old” | Age alone says nothing about how it performs | Run the nine tests |
| “A competitor has a new site” | Their site may not be working either | Compare their leads to yours if you can, not their looks |
| “I am bored of it” | Boredom is not a customer problem | Refresh the photos and headline, then retest |
| “A designer cold-emailed me” | A pitch is not a test result | Ask for the tests and the numbers behind it |
| “Rankings dropped” | Rankings move for many reasons, including competitors and Google changes | Check Search Console and the nine tests before you rebuild |
What a new site will not fix
A new website will not fix an unclear offer, thin content or a lack of reviews. It will not make Google rank you. It will not answer your phone. If the real problem is that nobody knows you exist, start with your Google Business Profile, reviews and local content. Our lead generation redesign guide covers what a better site can change.
Also remember what you already have. Some pages bring visitors and links today. A rebuild that drops them can cost you more than the old design ever did. See what to keep when redesigning.
Repair, refresh or rebuild
| Option | Fits when | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Repair | The structure is sound and the problems are specific | Piling fixes on an old base |
| Refresh | The look and content need updating, not the structure | A refresh that skips phones and speed |
| Rebuild | Four or more big fails, or the platform cannot be updated or secured | Losing search traffic if you skip redirects |
If you rebuild, protect what works. Google Search Central says: “It’s important to map your old site’s URLs to the URLs for the new site,” and to “keep the redirects for as long as possible, generally at least 1 year.” Our guides on redesigning without losing SEO and website migration cover the steps. For a longer comparison, read refresh vs redesign vs rebuild.
Cost is the next question for most owners. We break down the factors in how much a website redesign costs.
Your 15-minute test for today
You do not need a tool or a meeting. Do this now.
- Open the table at the top of this guide.
- Test signs 1, 3 and 4 first. They take about a minute each.
- Run PageSpeed Insights for sign 2 and note the lab numbers.
- Check your phone log and email for sign 6. Count the last three months.
- Read your homepage and two service pages for sign 7.
- Mark pass, small fail or big fail for each. Write the rating next to the date.
- Count the big fails and read your row in the scorecard.
- Pick one fix to do this week. Put the date to retest on your calendar.
If you are in Carlisle, Mechanicsburg, Camp Hill or anywhere in Central PA, add one check: search your main service plus your town on your phone. Notice who shows up and how their pages look on the same screen. That first view is what a local customer sees.
Common mistakes
| Mistake | Why it hurts | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Deciding by feel | You may rebuild what only needed a repair | Run the nine tests first |
| Redesigning for looks only | Phone use and speed stay broken | Test signs 1 and 2 before you pick a style |
| Switching platforms with no redirect plan | Old addresses stop working and traffic drops | Map every old address to a new one |
| Skipping tracking | You cannot judge the new site | Set up call and form tracking before launch |
| Waiting until the site fails completely | Leads leak for months first | Retest every year |
| Letting a builder own your domain and files | You cannot leave or edit | Register your domain in your own name |
| Throwing out good pages | You lose pages that bring visitors | Inventory the old site before you cut |
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my website needs to be replaced?
Run nine tests: phone use, speed, security warnings, editing, look, results, accuracy, accessibility and software. Count the big fails. If you have zero or one, repair the site. If you have four or more, price a rebuild. Two or three means a refresh that fixes the worst problems first.
How often should a small business redesign its website?
There is no fixed schedule. Judge the site by what it does, not by its age. Review it once a year with the nine tests. Rebuild when the structure, the platform or the results say it is time, not when a calendar says so.
Is a website that is a few years old too old?
Not necessarily. Age matters less than whether the site works on phones, loads fast, stays secure and shows correct information. A five-year-old site that passes the tests can outperform a new one that fails them.
Can I fix these problems myself?
Some, yes. You can fix hours, photos, headlines, tap-to-call and a missing page. Structure, platform and speed problems that run deep need a developer. Start with the cheap fixes, then retest before you decide on a rebuild.
Will a new website hurt my Google rankings?
It can, if addresses change with no redirects or if pages disappear. Google says to map old URLs to new ones and keep redirects for as long as possible, generally at least one year. Plan the move before launch. See our guide on redesigning without losing SEO.
How much does a new website cost?
At Webfactory Media, a website base build starts at $6,500, and most projects run $12,000 to $25,000. Copywriting is always included. Your price depends on pages, features and content. Our guide on what drives redesign cost explains the factors.
Should I redesign or just refresh my website?
Refresh when the structure works and the look or copy is tired. Redesign or rebuild when four or more tests show deep problems, such as a layout that fails on phones or a platform nobody can update. Our refresh vs redesign vs rebuild guide compares the three.
What should I do first if I think I need a new site?
Run the nine tests and write down the results. Then audit what you have before you spend anything. A short audit shows what to keep and what to cut, and it gives any designer a clear starting point. Our website audit guide shows how.
Next steps
Run the nine tests this week. Fill in the scorecard. Fix the easy fails. If you have four or more big fails, get quotes and plan the move before you start. With two or three, fix the worst problems first.
If you want a visitor’s view of your site, try our free Website Teardown. Or talk it through with us. We offer a free marketing review, and we will tell you when a repair is enough.
Related guides
- website redesign guide
- Website Refresh vs Redesign vs Rebuild: Which Does Your Site Need?
- Website Redesign Checklist for Small Businesses
- Website Audit Before a Redesign: 7 Things to Check First
- How Much Does a Website Redesign Cost? What Drives the Price
- website redesign service
Want help with this in Carlisle or Central PA?
Webfactory Media is a Carlisle, PA agency. See our Carlisle web design and website redesign pages, or call (888) 849-2397 and we will look at your site for free.



