Opens in a new tab

How to Increase Your Website Conversion Rate: 7 Fixes

Marketing
Alex Arce
on
October 17, 2026

Last reviewed November 2026.

Short answer

To increase your website conversion rate, first record how many visitors become calls and forms. Then fix the biggest drop: the first screen, the main button, the phone view, proof near the button, the form, page speed and your reply time. Change one thing at a time and compare the weeks before and after.

Most owners ask how to get more traffic. A better question is how to get more from the visitors you already have. This guide shows you how to find where visitors leave, which seven fixes to make, and how to test each change on a small site.

This guide is part of our small business web design guide.

In this guide

What conversion rate means

A conversion is any action you want a visitor to take. For a service business that is usually a phone call, a form or a booking. Your conversion rate is the share of visitors who take that action.

Google Analytics 4 calls these actions key events. Google Analytics Help defines a key event as “an event that measures an action that’s particularly important to the success of your business.” You choose which actions count.

The math is simple. Divide the visitors who converted by all visitors, then multiply by 100. If 1,000 people visit and 20 call or send a form, your rate is 2%.

Two more terms help:

  • Lead. A call, form or message from a person who wants your service.
  • Baseline. Your own rate before you change anything. Every test needs one.

You may see “good” rates quoted online. We skip them. The figures we found conflict with each other, count different things and rarely name a source. Your baseline is the only number that matters here.

The three leaks that cost you leads

A visit becomes a job in three steps. Each step can leak. If you fix the wrong one, nothing changes.

StepWhat happensSigns of a leakFixes that help
1. Visit to actionA visitor lands and decides whether to call or fill in the form.People leave fast. Few calls or taps on the phone number.Fixes 1 to 3, 6
2. Action to leadThe visitor starts the call or form and finishes it.Form starts with no sends. Calls that drop at once.Fixes 4, 5
3. Lead to jobYou get the lead and answer it.Leads arrive but few turn into booked work.Fix 7

For a local business, follow-up matters too, because a lead you answer late is a lead the next company may win. We cover that in speed to lead.

Find your biggest leak in 15 minutes

You can do this with no paid tool.

  1. Write down three numbers for the last 90 days: visitors, leads and your rate. If you do not track calls and forms yet, set that up first. See what to track and call tracking.
  2. Open your site on your own phone. Try to call and to send the form. Time how long it takes.
  3. Run the five-second test. Show your homepage to someone for five seconds. Ask what the business does and where. If they cannot tell you, fix 1 comes first.
  4. Check your last ten leads. How fast did you reply? How many became jobs? A slow reply points to fix 7.
  5. Look at your top three landing pages. Note which ones get visits but no leads. Start there.

Now you know which of the three leaks is biggest. The seven fixes below are in the order we would use them for a typical service site.

Fix 1: Say what you do in the first screen

Visitors decide fast, and they read little. Nielsen Norman Group found that on an average page of 593 words, people have time to read at most 28 percent of the words, and a more realistic figure is about 20 percent. That study is from 2008, so treat the exact numbers with care. Say the key thing first, in few words.

The first screen should answer three questions:

  1. What do you do?
  2. Who is it for, and where?
  3. What should I do next?

Here is sample wording for a made-up business. It shows the pattern and is not a real client.

WeakBetter
Welcome to our websiteFurnace repair and installation in Carlisle and nearby towns
Quality service you can trustCall today for a same-week visit. Free quote on new systems.
Learn moreCall now or request a quote

Cut splash screens, slow sliders, slogans with no service or town in them, and rows of buttons that compete. Our post on what a homepage should include goes deeper.

Fix 2: Give each page one main action

Decide what one action each page should drive. A service page might ask for a call. A contact page might ask for a form. When a page asks for five things, visitors may do none.

  • Use a button color that stands out from the page.
  • Use clear words: “Call now,” “Get a free quote,” “Book a visit.” Skip “Submit” and “Click here.”
  • Put the button in the first screen and again after each major section.
  • Make the phone number a tap-to-call link.
  • Never leave the action as plain text that cannot be tapped.

See what makes a landing page convert.

Fix 3: Make the phone version easy to use

Open your site on your own phone. Some of your visitors are likely holding one. The mobile version also matters for search. Google Search Central says it uses the mobile version of a site’s content for indexing and ranking, and tells owners to make sure the mobile site “contains the same content as your desktop site.”

Funnel graphic showing many visitors narrowing to a few leads and jobs
Visitors narrow to leads, and leads narrow to jobs. Fix the biggest drop first.

Buttons must be easy to hit. The W3C sets a minimum for pointer targets of at least 24 by 24 CSS pixels, with some exceptions. That is a floor. In our view, a call button should be larger than that, so a thumb can hit it.

Check these on a real phone:

  • Can you read the text without zooming?
  • Can you tap the phone number and start a call?
  • Can you hit each button without touching the wrong one?
  • Does a menu or pop-up cover the main message?
  • Does the form work with the phone keyboard?

If any answer is no, fix it before you spend on ads. See our mobile-ready tips and speed and mobile check.

Fix 4: Put real proof next to the button

People worry before they call. Proof calms that worry. Put it right beside your main button, not three screens away.

  • A short review with a first name and town, used with permission.
  • A photo of your real team or real work. Skip stock photos.
  • Licenses and insurance you actually hold.
  • Years in business and the towns you serve.

Keep it honest. A Federal Trade Commission rule prohibits creating, selling or buying fake reviews or testimonials, and a business can be liable for buying reviews it knew or should have known were false (see the Federal Trade Commission). Asking real customers is fine. Our guides on getting more Google reviews, social proof without fake reviews and website photos without stock show how.

Fix 5: Shorten the form

Each field is one more reason to quit. Ask only for what you need to reply: name, phone and a short message.

Online stores show the same pattern at larger scale. The Baymard Institute found the average checkout had 11.3 form fields in 2024, and says most sites need only 8. A contact form is not a checkout, but the lesson carries over. Cut what you do not need.

KeepCut or move later
NameCompany size, budget, “how did you hear about us” (ask on the phone)
Phone or emailSecond email, fax, mailing address
Short message or service typeLong free-text boxes, forced account sign-ups
  • Use clear labels and one column.
  • Say what happens next, such as “We reply within one business day.” Only say it if it is true.
  • Send people to a thank-you page that confirms the request. See thank-you page ideas.
  • Test the form yourself every month. A broken form is a silent leak.

More detail is in how many form fields a page should have.

Fix 6: Make pages load fast

Google lists three Core Web Vitals. web.dev says the main content should load within 2.5 seconds, pages should respond to input in 200 milliseconds or less, and layout shift should stay at 0.1 or below, measured at the 75th percentile of page loads.

These are Google’s targets for a good experience. Meeting them does not promise more leads. But a page that loads fast and responds right away is easier to use.

  • Compress large images.
  • Remove plugins and scripts you do not use, but keep your analytics and tracking tags.
  • Use good hosting and caching.
  • Run PageSpeed Insights and fix the top item first.

If you use WordPress, read how to speed up WordPress.

Fix 7: Reply to leads fast

A form fill is not a sale. It is a person who raised a hand. If nobody replies for a day, they may call the next business on the list.

  • Set a goal, such as replying to every form and missed call the same business day.
  • Send an automatic confirmation so the person knows you got it.
  • Return missed calls quickly.
  • Name who owns the reply, so it never falls through.
  • Track how many leads become jobs, not only how many arrive.

Google Ads can count a call as a conversion. Google Ads Help says it tracks a call as a conversion “when it lasts longer than a minimum length you set,” which helps you ignore very short calls. For simple follow-up ideas, see AI lead follow-up.

Which fix to make first

FixEffortMake it first if
1. First screen messageLowVisitors leave fast and your top says little.
2. One main actionLowPages have many buttons or none.
3. Phone versionLow to mediumYou check your own phone and something fails.
4. Proof near the buttonLowYou have good reviews but hide them.
5. Shorter formLowVisitors start the form but do not finish.
6. Page speedMediumPages feel slow on a phone.
7. Fast follow-upLowYou get leads but few become jobs.

If you are not sure, start with fixes 1 and 2. They cost little and touch every visitor. For a second opinion, our free Website Teardown shows what a visitor sees on your site.

Smartphone with a call button next to a checklist and stopwatch
A phone check takes ten minutes and finds most easy leaks.

How to test a change with little traffic

Most local sites do not have enough visitors for formal A/B tests. Use a plain before-and-after test instead.

  1. Record your baseline. Use at least four weeks of visitors and leads.
  2. Change one thing. Write the date and what you changed.
  3. Wait. Give it four to eight weeks, or longer if traffic is thin.
  4. Compare like with like. Check the same weeks and the same traffic sources. Seasons can fool you, especially in trades that peak in summer or winter.
  5. Keep or undo. If leads rose, keep it. If not, undo it and try the next fix.

A small change in a few days means little. Three extra calls in a week can be luck.

Want a site that does this for you? We design and build websites for local businesses. See our web design service, or if you are in Central PA, our web design in Carlisle, PA page.

A made-up example with the math

This example is made up. The numbers are round and are not from a real client or a forecast. Use it to learn the method.

Picture a small landscaping company in Central PA. Its site gets 800 visitors a month. Each new job brings in $400 of gross profit, which is what is left after labor and materials.

StepBeforeAfter one fixMath
Visitors800800Same traffic
Leads1624Short form and tap-to-call button
Conversion rate2%3%16 ÷ 800, then 24 ÷ 800
Jobs booked (1 in 4 leads)46Leads × 0.25
Gross profit$1,600$2,400Jobs × $400

Same visitors, two more jobs. Now see how fragile it is. If the company replies late and only 1 in 8 leads books, the 24 leads give 3 jobs and $1,200. That is less than the “before” row. The page and the reply work together. We cannot promise a result like this, and your numbers will differ.

Common mistakes

MistakeWhy it hurtsFix
Changing five things at onceYou cannot tell what worked.Change one thing and note the date.
Judging after a few daysSmall numbers swing at random.Wait four to eight weeks.
Buying traffic before fixing the pageYou pay more to lose the same share.Make fixes 1 to 5 first.
Vague claims and stock photosVisitors cannot trust what they cannot check.Use real photos and plain facts.
Hiding the phone numberFor most local service pages, calls are the main action (our view).Put it at the top and make it tap-to-call.
Never testing the formA broken form loses leads without a sound.Send a test every month.
Copying a benchmarkDefinitions differ and sources are thin.Beat your own baseline.
Ignoring reply timeA late reply may cost the job.Set a same-day goal.

A note for Central PA businesses

Check your own phone, because some visitors will use one. Name your towns on the page. Put your number where a thumb can reach it. If your trade has a busy season, fix the page before it starts, not in the middle of it.

If the fixes do not move the numbers, the site itself may be the limit. Our guides on choosing a web designer, briefing a web designer and what a small business website costs help you plan the next step. Also see website redesign for lead generation.

Frequently asked questions

What is a conversion rate on a website?

A conversion rate is the share of visitors who take an action you want, such as calling, sending a form or booking. Divide the people who took the action by total visitors, then multiply by 100. For a service business, count calls and form leads. Do not count page views.

What is a good conversion rate for a local service business?

There is no single good number. Published benchmarks conflict, mix up definitions and rarely name a source, so we do not quote one. Count calls and forms for the last 90 days, work out your own rate, and aim to beat it. Your trend over time tells you more than an industry average.

How long does it take to see results from conversion fixes?

Give a simple fix four to eight weeks if your site has steady traffic. With low traffic, wait longer and judge by calls and forms, not clicks. Do not read much into a few days of data. Check your numbers at the same point each month so seasons do not fool you.

Do I need A/B testing to increase my conversion rate?

Usually not. A small site may not get enough visitors for a fair A/B test. Change one thing, record the date, and compare the weeks before and after. That is a plain before-and-after test. Our guide on A/B testing with small traffic explains how to do it well.

Should I redesign my site or fix the page I have?

Fix the page you have if the layout is sound and you can edit it. A redesign makes sense when the site fails on phones, is hard to update, or does not match your business anymore. Read 9 signs you need a new website before you decide.

Will more traffic fix a low conversion rate?

No. More visitors to a page that does not convert gives you more of the same result, and you may pay for each one. Fix the first screen, the phone version, the form and your follow-up first. Then adding traffic makes more sense, because each visitor is worth more.

What tools do I need to track conversions?

Google Analytics 4 is free and can track forms once the form submission is collected as an event and marked as a key event. Google Search Console is free too, but it shows only search queries and clicks, not forms or calls. Add call tracking if phones matter to your business. Google Ads can count a call as a conversion when it lasts longer than a minimum length you set. A phone and a friend also work well for the five-second test.

Does the conversion rate differ by page?

Yes. A service page, a contact page and a blog post each convert differently. Look at your top landing pages one at a time. A blog post may bring visitors who are only learning, so a lower rate there is normal. Judge each page by its job.

Next steps

Pick the two fixes that fit your biggest leak. Make them this week, one at a time. Record the date. Check the numbers again in four to eight weeks.

If you would like a second set of eyes on your pages, we are happy to look at your site with you. There is no pressure to hire us. You can also start with our free Website Teardown.

More on landing pages

Alex Arce

I’m Alex Arce, founder and AI automation lead at Webfactory Media in Carlisle, PA, where I build AI-driven web design and marketing solutions. I’ve created 25+ custom automations, saving clients over 150 hours.

Related Post

accent heading

Explore proven strategies, real-world experiments, and practical insights we use every day to help businesses generate more leads, close more deals, and scale smarter.