Last reviewed November 2026.
Short answer
A website audit before a redesign is a short check of your current site in seven areas: search traffic, leads, speed and mobile, content, technical health, trust and tracking. Write down what works, what is broken and what you cannot measure. The result is a one-page list that tells your designer what to protect and fix.
A redesign built on guesses often repeats the old problems in a new color. An audit replaces guesses with facts. You can run a first pass yourself in about two hours of focused work, using free tools and your own phone.
This guide is part of our website redesign guide.
In this guide
- What a pre-redesign audit is for
- Before you start: get the logins
- Check 1: Search traffic
- Check 2: Leads and contact paths
- Check 3: Speed and mobile
- Check 4: Content
- Check 5: Technical health
- Check 6: Trust
- Check 7: Tracking
- Score your site and decide
- A made-up audit sheet with the math
- Turn findings into keep, fix and cut
- A two-hour plan
- Common mistakes
- Frequently asked questions
- Next steps
What a pre-redesign audit is for
An audit is a fact-finding step. It is not a design review, and it is not a full technical SEO study. It has three jobs.
- Find what to protect. Some pages bring in calls, links or search visits. You need to know which ones before anyone changes them.
- Find what to fix. Slow pages, broken forms, confusing menus and thin content show up here.
- Set a starting line. You cannot show a redesign helped unless you wrote down how things were before.
A local business has different needs than a large site. Phone calls matter as much as forms. Your Google Business Profile is part of your web presence. And you may have one person doing it all. This guide is built for that case.
Where does the audit fit? It comes first. Then you build a page-by-page list (see our guide to a website content inventory), decide what to keep when redesigning a website, and only then ask what the project should cost. Our redesign blueprint shows the whole path.
Before you start: get the logins
Many owners learn in this step that someone else controls part of their site. List each of these and note who holds the login.
| Account | Why you need it | If you do not have it |
|---|---|---|
| Domain registrar | Controls where your web address points. Needed at launch. | Ask the person who bought the domain. Look up the registrar and request a transfer of access. |
| Hosting | Where the site files live. Needed for backups. | Ask your current developer. Get a full backup in writing. |
| Site admin (WordPress or other) | Lets you see pages, forms and plugins. | Ask for an admin user account in your own name. |
| Google Search Console | Shows search clicks and indexing problems. | Add your site now so you can see its data and get alerts. |
| Google Analytics | Shows visits, landing pages and actions. | Ask the owner to add you as a user, or set up a new property today. |
| Google Business Profile | Feeds the map and your phone calls. | Request ownership through Google’s process. |
| Form and email tools | Where leads are sent. | Ask who receives the form emails today. |
If you cannot get Search Console or Analytics, start now. Once your site is added to Search Console, you can see its search data and get alerts about problems.
Check 1: Search traffic
Open Google Search Console and go to the Performance report. Two terms matter here. A click is, in Search Console Help’s words, “the number of times a user clicked your site from Google Search results.” An impression is “how many times your site appeared in Search results.” The default view covers the past three months, so change the date range to the longest one available.
Write down:
- Your top ten pages by clicks.
- Your top ten search terms by clicks, and by impressions.
- Pages with many impressions but few clicks. These may have weak titles or descriptions.
- Pages that used to get visits and no longer do.
Then open Google Analytics and see which pages people land on first. You do not need perfect numbers. You need to know which pages matter to the business.
Why it matters: these are the pages a redesign can hurt the most. If a page earns steady visits, it should not lose its address, main heading or main content without a plan. Google tells site owners to plan this: “It’s important to map your old site’s URLs to the URLs for the new site,” says Google Search Central. We cover the process in how to redesign a website without losing SEO.
Check 2: Leads and contact paths
Visits are not the goal. Calls and quote requests are. For the last few months, write down:
- How many calls came from the website, if you can tell.
- How many form entries came in.
- Which pages the visitor was on before they contacted you.
- How many of those contacts became paid jobs.
If you cannot answer these, that is a finding. Put it near the top. A new site you cannot measure is a new site you cannot improve.
Test every contact path yourself
- Fill out each form on the site with a test message. Use a different email than the one that receives it.
- Confirm the message arrives, and note how long it took.
- Call the number on the site from your cell phone. Does it ring the right place?
- Tap the phone number on a phone. Does it start a call?
- Check the spam folder for form emails.
Broken lead paths are cheap to fix and costly to leave. Fix them this week, not at launch. Our guide on redesigning for lead generation covers what a better contact path looks like.
Check 3: Speed and mobile
Run Google PageSpeed Insights on your home page and your two most important service pages. Run the mobile test first. The tool shows two kinds of data. Its PageSpeed Insights documentation says field data is “useful for capturing true, real-world user experience – but has a more limited set of metrics,” while lab data “is useful for debugging issues, as it is collected in a controlled environment.” Field data comes from real visitors. Lab data comes from a test run. Use field data to see how bad it is, and lab data to find the cause.
The three Core Web Vitals measure loading, response and stability. web.dev lists the “good” marks:
| Metric | What it measures | Good mark |
|---|---|---|
| Largest Contentful Paint (LCP) | How fast the main content appears | Within 2.5 seconds of when the page starts loading |
| Interaction to Next Paint (INP) | How fast the page reacts to a tap or click | 200 milliseconds or less |
| Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS) | How much the page jumps while loading | 0.1 or lower |
web.dev says to judge these at the 75th percentile of page loads, split by mobile and desktop. In plain words: most visits, not the best visit, should meet the mark. A small site may not have enough field data for a single page. The PageSpeed Insights documentation says the tool then falls back to origin-level data, which covers all of the site’s pages, and if that is also thin it shows no real-user data at all. Lab data is a separate section, so treat it as a clue, not a verdict.
Next, the human test. Use the site on your phone, on cell data, not on office Wi-Fi.
- Does the page jump around as it loads?
- Can you tap each button without zooming?
- Is the phone number a tap-to-call link?
- Is the text readable without pinching?
- Does the menu open and close cleanly?
- Does the form work with your thumb?
Mobile also matters for search. Google says it uses “the mobile version of a site’s content” for indexing and ranking, and asks you to “make sure that your mobile site contains the same content as your desktop site.” See Google’s mobile-first indexing guide. If your phone version hides content that the desktop version shows, that is a finding. Our guide on speed and mobile for landing pages goes further.
Check 4: Content
Read your main pages as a stranger would. Ask these questions.

- In five seconds, can I tell what this business does and where?
- Is anything out of date: services, hours, staff, prices, photos?
- Does the page answer the questions a customer has before calling?
- Is it written for the customer, or for the owner?
- Is there one clear next step?
Pay special attention to pages that bring in leads. They may look plain and still do the work. Good copy is often rewritten away in a redesign. If a page works, write down why.
Also look for pages that compete. Two pages about the same service, with slightly different wording, make it harder for search engines to choose. Mark them for merging. Does your site have the pages a local customer expects? Our list of what pages a small business website needs is a quick comparison.
This check is a first pass. The next step is the full page list, which our content inventory guide walks through.
Check 5: Technical health
You do not need to be a developer. Look for these.
| Item | How to check it | What a problem looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Broken links | Click your menu and key pages. Run a free link checker. | Pages that return an error or lead nowhere |
| Page titles and descriptions | Look at Search Console results, or view a page’s title in your browser tab. | Many pages share one title, or titles are blank |
| Blocked pages | Open Search Console’s page indexing report. | Important pages marked “noindex” or blocked |
| HTTPS | Load several pages and watch for a warning in the address bar. | A “not secure” notice or mixed content |
| Redirects | Try old addresses you know of. | Old links lead to an error page |
| Sitemap | Look in Search Console under Sitemaps. | No sitemap, or errors listed |
| Software updates | Ask your developer for the CMS and plugin versions. | Old versions, or nobody knows |
One warning on blocked pages. A noindex rule tells Google to drop the page. Google Search Central says Google will “drop that page entirely from Google Search results.” And if robots.txt also blocks the page, “the crawler will never see the noindex rule.” Both are easy to leave on by mistake when a site is built on a test address. Check that none of your key pages carry them.
Write each problem with the page address. “Contact page form fails on mobile” helps a builder. “Technical issues” does not. If addresses will change, our website migration guide covers moving a site safely.
Check 6: Trust
Trust is what makes a visitor pick up the phone. Check these items.
- Do real customer reviews appear on the site, and do they match what is on Google?
- Are the photos your own work and team, or only stock images?
- Are your name, address and phone number easy to find and written the same way as on your Google Business Profile? See NAP consistency.
- Do you show licenses, insurance or certifications you hold?
- Is there an About page with real people?
- Are the privacy policy and terms present and current?
Only list proof you can back up. If a claim cannot be checked, it should not move to the new site. Your Google Business Profile is worth a look here too, since many visitors see it before they see your site.
A short note on accessibility
Accessibility means people with disabilities can use your site. The W3C describes its guidelines as explaining “how to make web content more accessible to people with disabilities,” and encourages use of the latest version, WCAG 2.2. You do not need a full review at this stage. Do a quick pass: can you move through the menu and form with only the Tab key, is text easy to read against its background, and do images have descriptions? Our website accessibility basics guide has the starter list.
Check 7: Tracking
Last, check what you can measure. A redesign changes pages, buttons and forms. If tracking is not carried across, you lose the ability to tell what worked.
- Analytics is installed on every page.
- Key actions are recorded: phone taps, form sends and any other goal.
- Ad tags, if you run ads, fire on the right actions. See conversion tracking for local business.
- Call tracking numbers, if used, appear on the pages that need them. See call tracking for Google Ads.
- Search Console is verified for the exact version of your site people visit.
Write down what works and what does not. Ask the builder to carry every working item across and to test them before launch.
Score your site and decide
After the seven checks, give each one a score. Use a simple scale.
- 2 = solid. It works and you can prove it.
- 1 = mixed. It works in part, or you are not sure.
- 0 = broken or unknown. It fails, or you cannot measure it.
Add the scores. The top is 14. The bands below are a rule of thumb from us, not an industry standard. Use them to start a conversation, not to end one.
| Total | What it often points to | Next move |
|---|---|---|
| 11 to 14 | The site works. A refresh may be enough. | Fix the gaps, update copy and photos, and test again. |
| 6 to 10 | Real problems, but some strong parts. | A planned redesign that protects the strong pages. |
| 0 to 5 | Most areas fail or cannot be measured. | Fix the lead paths and tracking now, then consider a rebuild. |
Look at which checks scored 0, not just the total. A site with 12 points and a broken contact form needs that form fixed today. See refresh vs redesign vs rebuild for how the three options differ.
Planning a redesign? Ask us for a free marketing review of your current site. See our website redesign service.
A made-up audit sheet with the math
This example is made up. The business and the numbers are not from a real client. Use it to learn the format.

Picture a landscaping company in Mechanicsburg. The owner pulls three months of Search Console data and finds 150 search clicks in total. Four pages earn 120 of them.
| Step | Made-up figure | Math |
|---|---|---|
| Total search clicks, 3 months | 150 | From the Performance report |
| Clicks to the top four pages | 120 | Added from the page list |
| Share of clicks on those four pages | 80% | 120 ÷ 150 |
| Form entries in 3 months | 9 | From the inbox |
| Test form sends that arrived | 1 of 2 | One form went to an old email |
| Jobs won from the site | 3 | From the owner’s notes |
| Site visits that led to a form | Cannot tell | No tracking on form sends |
Now read the sheet. Four pages carry 80 percent of the search clicks, so those four are the pages to protect. One of the two forms sends to an old address, so some leads may be lost today. And tracking is missing, so the owner cannot say what a visit is worth.
| Check | Score | Finding | Pile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Search traffic | 2 | Four pages earn 80% of clicks | Leave alone: keep addresses and headings |
| Leads | 0 | One form goes to an old email | Fix now |
| Speed and mobile | 1 | Home page images are very large | Fix in redesign |
| Content | 1 | Two pages cover lawn care | Merge in redesign |
| Technical health | 1 | Several broken footer links | Fix in redesign |
| Trust | 1 | Reviews on Google, none on site | Fix in redesign |
| Tracking | 0 | Form sends not recorded | Fix now |
The total is 6 of 14. In this made-up case that points to a planned redesign that protects the four key pages, plus two fixes that should not wait (the Leads and Tracking rows).
Turn findings into keep, fix and cut
The last step is to sort every finding into one of three piles.
| Pile | What goes in it | Example from the sheet above |
|---|---|---|
| Fix now | Broken forms, wrong phone numbers, blocked pages. Do not wait for the project. | Send the old form to the right inbox. |
| Fix in the redesign | Structure, copy gaps, design, speed and trust work. | Resize the home page images. Add a reviews section. |
| Leave alone | Things that work. Write them down so nobody changes them by accident. | The four pages that earn most clicks. |
The third pile protects you. It is how you avoid a site that looks better and performs worse. Put the sheet in one shared file. Every row should end in an action or a decision. If a row does not, cut it.
Then plan the moves. If any address will change, list each old address and where it will go. Google says to use server side permanent redirects if technically possible, and to “keep the redirects for as long as possible, generally at least 1 year” (Google Search Central). Hand that list to your builder, along with your redesign checklist.
A two-hour plan
You can run a first pass in one sitting. Here is a time-boxed plan.
- Minutes 0 to 15: List the logins. Mark any you do not hold and send access requests.
- Minutes 15 to 40: Search traffic. Pull the top pages and terms from Search Console.
- Minutes 40 to 60: Leads. Test each form and phone number. Record last quarter’s counts.
- Minutes 60 to 80: Speed and mobile. Run PageSpeed Insights on three pages. Use the site on your phone.
- Minutes 80 to 100: Content, technical and trust. Read the main pages. Run a link checker.
- Minutes 100 to 110: Tracking. List what is recorded and what is not.
- Minutes 110 to 120: Score and sort. Fill in the sheet and make your three piles.
Central PA owners often run seasonal work. If you serve Carlisle, Mechanicsburg or Harrisburg and your busy season is near, ask your builder how the timeline lines up with it. See how long a redesign takes. Do the fixes in the “fix now” pile first. They pay off even if the redesign is months away.
Common mistakes
| Mistake | Why it hurts | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Auditing only what you see every day | The pages that bring leads may be ones you rarely open. | Start from Search Console and Analytics, not from the menu. |
| Skipping the starting numbers | You cannot show the new site did better. | Save clicks, calls and form counts before any change. |
| Trusting a tool score alone | A site can pass a tool and still feel clumsy. | Use tools for clues. Add the phone test. |
| Never testing the contact paths | Broken forms lose leads quietly. | Send a test message from every form. |
| Trying to fix everything | An audit finds more than a project can solve. | Pick the items tied to your goal. |
| Keeping the audit in your head | The builder cannot act on it. | Put it on one page with three piles. |
| Ignoring access | Missing logins can stall a launch. | Collect every login first. |
| Changing addresses with no plan | Old links and search results can lead to errors. | Map old addresses to new ones before launch. |
If a launch has already happened and traffic dropped, read what to do when traffic drops after a redesign.
Frequently asked questions
What is a website audit before a redesign?
It is a short review of your current site that tells you what to keep, what to fix and what to measure before anyone designs a new one. It covers search traffic, leads, speed, content, technical health, trust and tracking. The output is a one-page list, not a long report.
How long does a pre-redesign audit take?
For a small business site, plan on about two hours of focused work, spread over a few days. Getting logins can take longer than the audit itself. Larger sites with hundreds of pages take more time, and a content inventory is the part that grows fastest. See our guide to building a content inventory.
Do I need paid tools to audit my website?
No. Google Search Console, Google Analytics, PageSpeed Insights and your own phone cover most of what a small site needs. A free link checker helps. Paid crawlers become useful on larger sites, but they are not required to decide what to keep.
How is an audit different from a content inventory?
An audit looks at how the whole site performs. A content inventory is a page-by-page list of what you have. The audit tells you which areas are weak. The inventory tells you which pages to keep, merge or cut. Do the audit first, then the inventory.
What should I do if I cannot get into Search Console or Analytics?
Start the access request now and write it down. Once a property is added, you can see its data and get alerts about problems. If a former agency or employee owns the account, ask the owner to add you as a user. If that fails, set up new accounts today.
Can an audit show that I do not need a redesign?
Yes. Sometimes the problems are a broken form, slow images or thin pages, and those can be fixed without a new design. The decision table in this guide helps you sort fixes from a real redesign. Our guide to refresh vs redesign vs rebuild goes deeper.
Should I audit before or after I get a redesign quote?
Before, if you can. An audit tells you which pages must be protected and which problems the project must solve. You can then compare quotes against the same list. Our guide to what a redesign costs explains what drives the price.
Who should run the audit, me or the agency?
You can run the first pass yourself with this guide, because you know your business and your leads. A good agency will do its own technical review as well. Bring your list to that conversation. It shows you know what matters and makes it easier to judge what you are told.
Next steps
Here is the short version. Get the logins. Run the seven checks. Score each one. Sort the findings into fix now, fix in the redesign and leave alone. Save your starting numbers.
If you want a second pair of eyes, we are glad to look at your site with you. There is no pressure to hire us. You can also start with a free tool: our Website Teardown shows what a visitor sees on your site.
Keep reading
- website redesign guide
- Website Content Inventory: list every page and give it a job.
- What to Keep When You Redesign a Website: the keep, improve, merge and remove rules.
- Website Redesign Checklist for Small Businesses: ten things to settle before you hire.
- website redesign service



